SINDHI SENTIMENTS
To,
The Editor,
The Times of India,
Bennett Coleman & Co., Ltd.,
The Times of India Building,
Dr. D. N. Road,
Mumbai 400001
Dear Sir,
Ever since I entered Secondary School in 1960, my day invariably begins by spending atleast 30 minutes going through The Times of India7. A rewarding habit that has stayed with me till date.
For the first time in my life I felt a little sad and let down by the daily which has always been a source of inspiration and an inseparable part of my life. This was on Sunday 21st instant.
While appreciating your greeting the Maharashtrian readers on ‘Gudi Padwa’ and your readers in Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh on ‘Ugadi’ and in Kashmir on 'Navreh' you did not miss out on the miniscule Parsi community on ‘Navroze’. Then how is it that you missed out the enterprising Sindhi community that celebrates ‘Chetichand’, its new year, on the same day?
This is not a complaint or written with any rancor or anger but a spontaneous lament on behalf of a community that has not received its due inspite of being the driving force behind several educational, medical and philanthropic institutions in this country.
As is the case with most communities, the youth today in their anxiety to become a part of the 'Global Village' tend to ignore their own identity - culture, heritage and language. And, in our case, on account of the absence of a state of our own, the problem is even more acute. Not only is there a lack of awareness but also the lack of desire to become aware and an aversion to being identified as Sindhis.
It was for this very reason that I began publishing the quarterly magazine "Sindhishaan" (latest copy enclosed), since 2001, in English and targeted the second post-partition generation to generate interest in their roots and take pride in their heritage.
So my humble request - next year do not forget the Sindhis. When the youth of the community realize that "The Times of India" recognizes them and remembers them - they will start feeling proud to be Sindhis and not be ashamed in revealing that they are Sindhis -whose parents were refugees but are now the citizens of the great nation — India.
Best regards,
R. M. Butani
From: Sindhishaan-Editor [mailto:editor@sindhishaan.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 2:56 PM
To: 'toieditorial@timesgroup.com'
Subject: Lest you forget this year
The Editor,
The Times of India
Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd.
Mumbai - 400 001
Please find attached herewith copy of my communication to you last year.
Best Regards,
Ranjit Butani
Editor
SINDHISHAAN - voice of the Sindhis
From: Sindhishaan-Editor [mailto:editor@sindhishaan.com]
Sent: Friday, March 31, 2006 2:40 PM
To: 'toieditorial@timesgroup.com'
Subject: Lest you forget this year
To,
The Editor
The Times of India
Bennett Coleman & Co. Ltd.
The Times of India Building,
Dr. D. N. Road, Mumbai 400 001
Dear Sir,
At the cost of being a pain in the ………. I am compelled to communicate the hurt and pain at your having ignored my community's - the Sindhi community's New Year 'Chetichand' in your publication yesterday, inspite of my reminder dated 29th instant.
Off course I cannot and do not demand any explanation for this omission but I think I'm justified in seeking a response as a courtesy to your readers and deserve an answer for your determination of not wanting to recognize the presence of my community. Do you have something against the Sindhis?
A line in clarifying your stand will be highly appreciated.
Best regards,
Ranjit Butani
Editor
SINDHISHAAN - voice of the Sindhis
Subject : Times of India
Dear Ranjit Butani,
I agree with you that we should not only preserve our identity but also assert it. The next generation of the global village also needs roots. More so because they are rubbing shoulders with varied cultures.
Aruna Jethwani
Dear Mr. Butani,
I have your communication dated 11th April, 2006 in connection with indifference shown by the Times of India towards Sindhi New Year "Cheti Chand".
It is indeed strange that Times of India should show such an attitude. Please be rest assured that I shall take up the matter with them through appropriate Forum and I am sure that we shall achieve our object.
Best regards,
Dr. Ram Buxani